Why do we always have the best advice for our friends but make the worst choices for ourselves? Science explains the paradox—and how to fix it.

⏬ Auto Scroll

Why You’re a Great Life Coach for Your Friends but Completely Clueless About Your Own Problems

Ever noticed how you’re basically Dr. Phil when your friends need advice, but when it’s your own life? Total trainwreck.

A confused person looking at a mirror, symbolizing self-sabotage and the paradox of giving great advice but not taking it.


You can break down someone’s toxic relationship like a seasoned therapist, drop some financial wisdom like a Wall Street guru, and even give step-by-step strategies on how to move on from an ex. But when it’s your problem? Your brain suddenly goes into “404 Error: Logic Not Found.”

“Why is it that I can clearly see what’s best for my friends, but when it’s me, I’m out here making the worst decisions of my life?”

Your Brain Is Playing Tricks on You 

Turns out, science has an answer for why we’re all walking contradictions. There’s something called Solomon’s Paradox—the phenomenon where we’re way better at giving advice than taking it (source).

Why Does This Happen? 

🔬 Psychologists found that when we think about other people’s problems, we take a step back, see the big picture, and think rationally (study). 💔 But when we’re in the middle of our own drama, emotions hijack our brain like a bad soap opera.

Essentially, when you’re advising a friend, your brain is like: 🧠 “This is easy. Just dump him, focus on yourself, and level up.” But when you’re dealing with your own breakup? 💀 “But what if he changes? What if I never find love again? What if I just… text him one last time?”

The Battle Between Logic & Emotion Your brain has two main decision-making systems:

✔️ Logical Brain (prefrontal cortex) → "Just block their number and move on." 

❌ Emotional Brain (limbic system) → "But what if they realize I’m their soulmate tomorrow?"

And guess what? Emotion almost always wins.

That’s why your advice is solid for others but your own choices are a dumpster fire.


The Psychological Reasons Behind This Mess 

1️⃣ You’re Too Close to the Situation When it’s someone else’s issue, you see it from a third-person perspective, like a movie. But when it’s your problem, you’re the main character—and emotions cloud your thinking (research).

2️⃣ The Action-Intention Gap You know what to do. You just don’t do it.

You know eating healthy is good, but you still order pizza. You know you should move on, but you still check their Instagram at 2 AM.

3️⃣ Your Brain Is Literally Addicted Studies show that emotional attachments trigger the same brain areas as drug addiction (study). That’s why you keep texting your ex like an addict chasing a dopamine hit.


How to Hack Your Own Brain Since your brain clearly can’t be trusted, here’s how to outsmart it:

🧠 Talk to Yourself Like You’re a Friend: Instead of thinking "Why am I like this?" Try: "If my best friend were in this situation, what would I tell them?" Studies show that using third-person self-talk helps you make better decisions (study).

📝 Write It Out Like You’re a Therapist: Literally write advice to yourself as if you were your own life coach. Seeing things on paper makes them feel less overwhelming.

⏳ Use the 5-Second Rule: If you know you should do something, count down 5-4-3-2-1 and do it before your brain talks you out of it (Mel Robbins' method).

🧐 Reframe the Question: Instead of: “Why is this happening to me?” Ask “What’s the smallest action I can take right now to fix this?”

Final Thoughts: 

Are You the Guru or the Student? You have two choices: 

1️⃣ Keep being the therapist for your friends while your own life stays a hot mess. 

2️⃣ Start applying your genius-level advice to yourself.

Either way, just don’t be the life coach whose own life is falling apart behind the scenes. 😬

🔥 Tag a friend who needs to hear this! #SelfImprovement #Psychology #Mindset #WhyAmILikeThis #LifeCoachButClueless #PersonalGrowth

Comments

Mikky Oscarino blog

Show more